wet n wildColor Icon Cream Eyeliner Eyeshadow Multi-Stick, Moisturizing, Nourishing Velvety Cream-to-Powder Buildable & Blendable Formula, Cruelty-Free & Vegan - Ros-I-Locks

Exactly as expected, I needed this as I was cosplaying and purchased a few colors. The thing that drew me in was the tip as it’s easily able to paint on your face in the exact area you need rather that a thicker blotchier face paint. Is nice and small and easy to carry either with you or in a bag. The outer shell was nice and sturdy so you won’t have to worry about it breaking. It sticks on to your face like butter and using a basic make up remover Itl come off easy. As long as your not going swimming with it, it is decently waterproof.

This brand being so inexpensive I did wonder about the quality of it. So I purchased several to try for myself. The quality is quite good as I’ve spent far more on similar brands in the past. Now I’m thinking WHY spend more. Great versatile makeup pencils.

Bought this to use for my daughter's scarecrow makeup for halloween. Worked great for this purpose. It was a little thicker than I wanted only because she's so tiny. But we made it work. I'm not sure how you'd use this for actual makeup/eyeliner because of how thick the pencil is. But it worked for what we needed it for. The black was solid and did not require going over the area a million times to get it to show up. Came off with makeup remover fairly quickly. Wasn't sticky or uncomfortable feeling on her face. Unsure if it would be waterproof. We didn't really have a situation that put that to the test.

Love this eye pencil it serves many functions. I love sephora brands and this pencil is right up there. I use it under my eyes and as a lipliner and even a contour eye shadow. Its a pencil that dries down to powder super versatile and ideal for traveling or a night out when you don't want to luv a ton of products. I give them away as gifts to all ages.

Why did you pick this product vs others?:I ordered this because I needed a eyeliner that was creamy and would go in my water line. This looked like it would work. It is creamy and it will go lots of places. It would probably be a great base for eyeshadow etc. However, it won't go in my waterline. I cannot find one that will. I had to give it 3 stars for that reason. I'll continue to look for one that will go there for me without being too sharp.

Waterproof:Great item, great priceWhy did you pick this product vs others?:The color was perfect, not too light, not too dark. I will be buying it again

I had eye surgery awhile back and since then my eyes get very irritated by the powder shadows but this is perfect, it doesn't irritate my eyes, it stays on and the color is very pretty, you can lighten it up by smoothing it out or make it darker by adding a little more and it comes off just as easily as it goes on.

Color:Pearl white, shimmery rose pink, matte light brown, dark brown, and blackStay put:They stay creamy throughout the day, they don’t really dry down. They can be set with translucent powder or even powder eye shadow to build the colorShimmer:AWhy did you pick this product vs others?:Trying different styles of cream sticks for quick ease looks